How We Tested
We evaluated each dictation tool using a standardized testing protocol: 500 words of pre-written text across three categories (general prose, technical content, and conversational speech). Each tool was tested on the same hardware (MacBook Pro M3, 16GB RAM), in the same quiet environment, with the same speaker. We measured raw accuracy (before corrections), effective accuracy (after AI post-processing), and time-to-text latency.
What to Look For in Dictation Software
Accuracy is the most important factor — even 2% lower accuracy means correcting errors every few sentences. Beyond accuracy, consider: platform support (Mac, Windows, mobile), offline capability, pricing model (subscription vs one-time), and integration with your workflow.
Cloud vs Local Processing
Cloud-based tools (Wispr Flow, Otter.ai) send your audio to remote servers for processing. This typically delivers better accuracy and faster results, but requires an internet connection and means your voice data leaves your device. Local tools (SuperWhisper, MacWhisper, OpenAI Whisper) process everything on your machine. Accuracy is slightly lower, but your data stays completely private. For medical, legal, or confidential work, local processing is strongly recommended.
Free vs Paid: Is It Worth Paying?
Free tools (Google Docs Voice Typing, Microsoft Dictate) typically achieve 85-92% accuracy. Paid tools ($5-$15/month) reach 95-99%. The difference sounds small, but in practice it means correcting 1-2 errors per paragraph vs 5-8 errors. For anyone who dictates more than 30 minutes per day, the time saved by better accuracy pays for the subscription within days.